The Onsite Manager Report, Episode 2: Locked In? The Appeal That Tried to Cap Management Rights

The Onsite Manager Report Episode 2: The Onsite Manager Report, Episode 2: Locked In? The Appeal That Tried to Cap Management Rights

By Tom from TheOnsiteManager.com.au

Welcome to The Onsite Manager Report, a short explainer series on the rulings, rules and risks that matter to Queensland onsite managers. In Episode 2, Nick looks at a question that goes to the value of every management rights business: can a body corporate keep extending its caretaking agreement, again and again?

The Onsite Manager Report, Episode 2 (2 min 20 sec)

What happened

At Atlantis West, a Queensland community titles scheme under the Standard Module, owners carried a motion at the annual general meeting to add an option extending the caretaking agreement by 1 year and 10 months, from 5 January 2032 to 4 November 2033.

One owner challenged the resolution. His theory: a caretaking agreement can be topped up only once, by a single extension of up to five years. That would cap Standard Module agreements at 15 years (10 + 5) and Accommodation Module agreements at 30 years (25 + 5).

On 18 September 2024 the adjudicator dismissed the application (Atlantis West [2024] QBCCMCmr 340). The owner appealed, and in January 2026 the QCAT Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal.

How the rules work (Standard Module, s 140)

  • Each new option is capped. A subsequent right or option of extension or renewal can be for no longer than five years.
  • The ten-year ceiling. On the day the body corporate passes the resolution approving it, the unexpired term of the engagement can’t be more than ten years.
  • Proper approval. The body corporate has to approve the amendment properly; at Atlantis West, by a motion at a general meeting.
  • Follow those rules and an agreement can be extended more than once. There is no one-extension limit.

Why it matters

The caretaker’s lawyers said most agreements have been extended more than once, so a win for the owner could have put many of them in doubt.

The debate isn’t over. On 5 November 2026 the Unit Owners Association of Queensland, an owners’ lobby group, argued that a majority vote alone doesn’t make an extension reasonable, and called for limits on repeated extensions and competitive tendering. That is one side of the argument, but it shows where reform pressure may come from.

Key takeaways for onsite managers

  • Know your expiry date, and every option in your agreement.
  • Keep the remaining term within your module’s cap.
  • Give owners clear information before an extension vote.
  • Keep an eye on reform.

Case citation

Stevens v Body Corporate for Atlantis West CTS 8790 & Anor [2026] QCATA 2 (delivered January 2026). Read the decision on AustLII.

For management rights news, listings and resources, visit theonsitemanager.com.au. Onsite managers can also join TheOnsiteManager here.

General information only, not legal advice. Outcomes turn on the facts and the scheme documents. Speak to a strata solicitor or the Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management (BCCM) before acting.

← The 1 January 2027 Smoke Alarm Deadline: What Queensland Onsite Managers Need to Do Now
We're recruiting plastering and ceiling repairs suppliers now. Do you offer this service? List your business