The Onsite Manager Report, Episode 1: The $311,958 Termination That Backfired
By Tom from TheOnsiteManager.com.au
Welcome to The Onsite Manager Report, a short explainer series on the rulings, rules and risks that matter to Queensland onsite managers. In Episode 1, Nick breaks down a post-mortem of a termination that went badly wrong: one garden bed, one sprinkler pipe, and a bill for $311,958.
What happened
In 2021, the body corporate at the Crown community titles scheme in Queensland sent its caretaker remedial action notices. One of them listed 37 alleged breaches. On 2 November 2021, owners voted to terminate the caretaking agreement, and the caretaker was refused access to its office.
On 16 October 2024, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) ruled that the termination was unlawful and ordered the body corporate to pay damages of $311,958: about $286,000 for the caretaking agreement and about $26,000 for letting, plus most of the caretaker’s legal costs.
Why the termination failed
- The first notice was defective. It said only that the body corporate “reserved its rights”. It never warned that the agreement could be terminated, and the rules say it must.
- The vote came too soon. The law sets out steps in order: a valid remedial action notice, a failure to comply, then an ordinary resolution by secret ballot. Here, the vote happened before a valid notice was even in place.
- Reasonableness. A body corporate must act reasonably, including in how it votes on termination. Of the 37 alleged breaches, only six were pressed at the hearing and only three were proven: aerating garden beds, cleaning sprinkler pipework, and speaking to the body corporate manager instead of the committee’s nominated representative. The Tribunal found that wasn’t enough to justify ending a long-term agreement.
- The lockout. Refusing the caretaker access to its office breached the letting agreement as well.
The damages
The Tribunal assessed $286,075 for the loss of the caretaking agreement and $25,883 for the loss of letting income, a total of $311,958.
Key takeaways for onsite managers
- When a notice arrives, read it carefully.
- Reply in writing.
- Keep your records.
- A breach on paper is not always grounds to terminate.
- If you sit on a committee, follow every step, in order: valid notice, failure to comply, then an ordinary resolution by secret ballot.
Case citation
Linali Pty Ltd as trustee for the Chakra Family Trust v Body Corporate for Crown CTS 41282 [2024] QCAT 446 (delivered 16 October 2024). Read the decision on AustLII.
For management rights news, listings and resources, visit theonsitemanager.com.au. Onsite managers can also join TheOnsiteManager here.
General information only, not legal advice. Outcomes turn on the facts and the scheme documents. Speak to a strata solicitor or the Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management (BCCM) before acting.